Video Update by Mark Smith, Four Boxes Diner

Today’s, the U.S. Supreme Court issued significant orders in two key Second Amendment cases: Bianchi v. Brown and Srour v. NYC. Let’s break down what these decisions mean for gun owners and the broader implications for gun rights in America.

The Bianchi v. Brown Case: Maryland’s “Assault Weapon” Ban

The Supreme Court denied certiorari in Bianchi v. Brown, a case challenging Maryland’s “assault weapon” ban. This denial is particularly noteworthy because the Court specified that it was “before judgment,” indicating that they are not ready to hear this case as it has not reached a final judgment at the appellate level.

This decision, while disappointing for Second Amendment advocates, was not entirely unexpected. The Fourth Circuit, which is handling the case, has not yet issued a final ruling. The Supreme Court’s refusal to hear the case at this stage suggests they are waiting for a complete record and a definitive ruling from the lower courts before considering it.

The Illinois Cases: A Glimmer of Hope?

Interestingly, the Supreme Court has not yet made a decision on the Illinois cases, which involve more recent gun ban laws. These cases challenge a broader and more modern iteration of gun control, specifically targeting semi-automatic rifles with specific features.

The fact that the Court has not denied certiorari in these cases might indicate they are still under consideration. These cases could be seen as better candidates for Supreme Court review because they address newer legislative approaches to gun control, potentially providing a more relevant and current context for the Court’s interpretation of the Second Amendment.

Srour v. NYC: Concealed Carry Permits

In Srour v. NYC, the Supreme Court also denied a motion to lift a stay on a favorable Second Amendment ruling regarding New York City’s concealed carry permit requirements. The original ruling found that the “good moral character” requirement for permits was unconstitutional. The Supreme Court’s denial to lift the stay means that the favorable ruling is on hold, maintaining the status quo for now.

What This Means Going Forward

For gun rights supporters, today’s news is a mixed bag. While the denial in the Bianchi case is disappointing, it doesn’t close the door on future Supreme Court intervention once the lower courts have issued a final judgment. The Illinois cases still offer a potential pathway for the Court to address modern gun control measures.

Mark Smith, host of Four Boxes Diner, emphasizes that while today’s decisions are not the victories many hoped for, they are part of the ongoing legal battle for Second Amendment rights. The Supreme Court’s actions suggest a strategic approach, waiting for more fully developed cases to set a precedent.

Stay Engaged and Informed

It’s crucial for Second Amendment supporters to stay informed and engaged. Legal battles are often long and complex, and today’s decisions are just one part of the larger fight for gun rights. Follow Four Boxes Diner on social media for updates and analysis on these important issues.

Let’s keep advocating for our rights and remain hopeful that future rulings will favor the Second Amendment. The fight continues, and with continued support and vigilance, we can work towards protecting our constitutional rights.

Follow our friend Mark Smith at Four Boxes Diner for more updates and analysis on Second Amendment cases and other relevant legal issues.