A battle over 100 words: Judge tentatively siding with California AG over students' gender identification

A battle over 100 words: Judge tentatively siding with California AG over students' gender identification
By: FOX News - Politics Posted On: April 20, 2024 View: 12

That is the court fight some parents in California are waging against Democratic lawmakers and the Newsom Administration, who are trying to stop voters from a proposed ballot measure that would require schools to notify parents if a child is changing their gender. The initiative would also protect female sports from transgender athletes (born males) and mandate that students use school facilities consistent with their birth gender.

Polls show a majority of Californian voters support the measures. However, the state legislature, where Democrats enjoy a super majority, refused to hear the bill, and Democrat State Attorney General Rob Bonta changed the initiative's title from "Protect Kids of California Act" to the "Restrict Rights of Transgender Youth" initiative.

CALIFORNIA LAWMAKERS ADVANCE BILL CREATING GENEALOGY OFFICE TO DETERMINE REPARATIONS ELIGIBILITY

Newsom looking off to the side.

California's parents are pushing back against democratic lawmakers and the Newsom administration concerning a proposed measure that forces schools to notify parents if their child changes their gender. (Chip Somodevilla/Getty Images)

Supporters also say Bonta changed the required 100-word summary of the initiative in a negative, misleading and pejorative way that they claim makes it nearly impossible to gather signatures or raise money.

"His bias on these issues is clear, and he's allowed to have his opinion," says Dean McGee of the Liberty Justice Center, which brought the lawsuit against Bonta. "What he's not allowed to do is mess with the democratic process in California. Rebrand this initiative in a way that makes it likely to fail, instead of giving it a fair shot at the ballot."

CALIFORNIA BILL AIMS TO BAN NO-PET POLICIES, ANIMAL FEES AT RENTAL HOUSING PROPERTIES

California Attorney General giving an interview.

California Attorney General Rob Bonta is being accused of changing a measure's title from "Protect Kids of California Act" to the "Restrict Rights of Transgender Youth" initiative. (Loren Elliott/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

According to state statute, the Attorney General is required to "give a true and impartial statement of the purpose of the measure" so that it "shall neither be an argument, nor be likely to create prejudice, for or against the proposed measure." 

On Thursday night, a judge tentatively denied the parents' lawsuit, saying statutes also give the Attorney General "considerable latitude in preparing a title and summary" and "only upon clear and convincing proof" that the title and summary is "false, misleading, or inconsistent with the requirements" of the (elections code), can a judge step in.

NEWSOM REFUSES TO BACK FELLOW DEMS TAKING ON GOOGLE, BIG TECH THROUGH NEWS LINK LEGISLATION

Gavin Newsom

The Newsom administration is facing a fight against California parents in court over a measure that requires schools to notify parents if their child is changing genders. (Myung J. Chun/Los Angeles Times via Getty Images)

Sacramento County Superior Court Judge Stephen Acquisto previously served as the chief deputy legal affairs lawyer for then Governor Jerry Brown.

The parent activist group cited research showing that most voters only read an initiative's title and summary. It claims changing words such as "protect," "ensure," and "fairness" to "require, restrict and prohibit" typically doom measures to fail at the ballot box.

CALIFORNIA SCHOOL BOARD PRESIDENT ORDERED TO PAY LEGAL FEES AFTER LGBTQ FLAG DEBATE, DEATH THREATS

Rob Bonta, attorney general of California, responds during an interview.

California parents are calling for Rob Bonta, attorney general of California, to be "conflicted out." (Loren Elliott/Bloomberg via Getty Images)

"He's attempting to bypass California's abilities to evaluate this issue neutrally by writing a biased summary that people will be unlikely to support," claims McGee. Leaders of Protect Kids California also say Bonta, a potential gubernatorial candidate, should be "conflicted out" because he's already suing to stop the Chino Valley School District from adopting a similar policy.

CLICK HERE TO GET THE FOX NEWS APP  

Bonta's office issued this statement.

"Under California law, the Attorney General's Office is responsible for issuing official titles and summaries describing the chief purpose and points of every proposed initiative... and stand by our title and summary for this measure."

Judge Acquisto heard arguments Friday afternoon challenging his ruling. The parents’ group says it will likely appeal and hope to get on the 2026 ballot.

Read this on FOX News - Politics Header Banner
  Contact Us
  • Postal Service
    YubNub Digital Media
    361 Patricia Drive
    New Smyrna Beach, FL 32168
  • E-mail
    admin@yubnub.digital
  Follow Us
  About

YubNub! It Means FREEDOM! The Freedom To Experience Your Daily News Intake Without All The Liberal Dribble And Leftist Lunacy!.